Don’t Even Think About It! The Effects of Antineutralization, Informational, and Normative Communication on Information Security Compliance

Authors

Jordan B. Barlow, University of St. ThomasFollow
Merrill Warkentin, Mississippi State UniversityFollow
Dustin Ormond, Creighton UniversityFollow
Alan Dennis, Indiana University - BloomingtonFollow

Abstract

Organizations use security education, training, and awareness (SETA) programs to counter internal security threats and promote compliance with information security policies. Yet, employees often use neutralization techniques to rationalize noncompliant behavior. We investigated three theory-based communication approaches that can be incorporated into SETA programs to help increase compliance behavior: (1) informational communication designed to explain why policies are important; (2) normative communication designed to explain that other employees would not violate policies; and (3) antineutralization communication designed to inhibit rationalization. We conducted a repeated measures factorial design survey using a survey panel of full-time working adults provided by Qualtrics. Participants received a SETA communication with a combination of one to three persuasion statements (informational influence, normative influence statement, and/or an antineutralization), followed by a scenario description that asked for their intentions to comply with the security policy. We found that both informational (weakly) and antineutralization communication (strongly) decreased violation intentions, but that normative communication had no effect. In scenarios where neutralizations were explicitly suggested to participants, antineutralization communication was the only approach that worked. Our findings suggest that we need more research on SETA techniques that include antineutralization communication to understand how it influences behavior beyond informational and normative communication.

Recommended Citation

Barlow, Jordan B.; Warkentin, Merrill; Ormond, Dustin; and Dennis, Alan (2018) "Don’t Even Think About It! The Effects of Antineutralization, Informational, and Normative Communication on Information Security Compliance," Journal of the Association for Information Systems, 19(8), .
Available at: https://aisel.aisnet.org/jais/vol19/iss8/3