JAIS Manuscript Categories – Information for Authors
Contributing to JAIS
The Journal of the Association for Information Systems (JAIS), the flagship journal of the Association for Information Systems (AIS), publishes scholarly contributions that represent the highest quality in the field of information systems. JAIS particularly welcomes contributions that provide theoretical insights that advance our understanding of information systems and information technology in organizations and society. New insights may include proposing a new theoretical model, challenging or clarifying existing theory, integrating diverse strands of research in information systems so as to advance new concepts and relationships, or developing a compelling argument for the field to develop a new theory. JAIS is inclusive in its coverage of topics, level and unit of analysis, theory, method, and philosophical and research approaches - reflecting all aspects of information systems research globally. For suggestions on building a contribution for JAIS, please see the editorial "What's in a contribution?"
Authors interested in the JAIS Promise Review Option should indicate this in their cover letter.
Authors should designate the manuscript category during submission. Please note that it is not currently possible to indicate the different types of categories directly in the review system, and so, the authors are asked to designate the manuscript category in their cover letter.
JAIS has the following manuscript categories:
1. Research Articles
This category is the most general category for manuscripts. It covers a range of genres, including studies involving qualitative and/or quantitative empirical studies, modeling, and design research. If authors are in doubt as to the category that is appropriate for their manuscript, they should submit the manuscript in this category and further explain the nature of the submission in their cover letter
2. Research Perspectives (Senior Editor: Dirk S. Hovorka)
The Research Perspectives category aims to provoke exciting discussion about issues that have a bearing on the community, its organization, and its mission. These papers may question or critique our institutions, our assumptions, our blinders, our disputes, our paradigms, how we define the boundaries of our subject, how we define research domains, what we privilege in our research and what we do not publish, among other things. A Research Perspectives Article may strive to question, observe, understand, and/or explain the objective and socially constructed worlds of information-systems researchers or may provide a philosophical and critical review of the evolution of thought of a senior scholar in the information-systems field, including how the evolution of his or her thought can contribute to the field in ways not previously recognized. Perspective papers should conclude by offering constructive guidance that will help the field to progress and develop. ”]
3. Review & Theory Development (Senior Editor: Guy Paré)
The Review and Theory Development (RTD) section of JAIS encourages the development of two main genres of manuscripts. The first genre refers to papers which use theory to structure the synthesis of one or several streams of research and then put forward a strategic platform for new research directions. The second genre aims at theory development or theory elaboration. In these papers, the review of the literature informs the development of a new theory or the elaboration of an existing theory. Prospective authors can take a variety of methods and approaches (e.g., realist review, meta-synthesis, meta-ethnography, grounded theory, critical interpretive synthesis) in their attempt to make a solid theoretical contribution. The RTD section will not consider papers which seek only to synthesize, summarize or map a mature or emergent body of knowledge (e.g., narrative, descriptive and scoping reviews) or reviews aimed at theory testing (e.g., meta-analysis). When submitting a manuscript to this section, authors should, in their cover letter, designate the manuscript as such, and nominate Guy Paré as the Senior Editor.
4. Interdisciplinary and Path Breaking Research (Senior Editor: Varun Grover)
As digital technology is being enmeshed with various forms of human activities, tools and contexts, IS scholars must strive to work with scholars in other fields to gain deeper understanding on the transformative nature of digital technology. This section of JAIS invites scholars to submit bold new ideas that offer fresh insights through rigorous and reflective research on emerging phenomenon. The focus should not be entirely on the novelty of the technology, but on the formulation of new theoretical language and empirical approaches that are necessitated by the novel phenomenon. Successful Interdisciplinary and Path Breaking Research submissions should challenge scholars in all disciplines including IS to rethink what has been taken for granted in the past, and provide an opportunity to break away from the familiar practice of scholarship. While the ideal submission should be simultaneously interdisciplinary and path breaking, submissions can emphasize either one of these aspects. A full description and instructions can be found here.
5. Editorial Notes
JAIS editorial notes are essays, commentaries, or reviews written primarily by the JAIS editorial board members. They are typically invited, although we may consider some unsolicited submissions. These editorial notes may point researchers into areas of research that editors feel have been neglected and that are important for the future of the field. They may offer thoughts about the journal’s review policies and practices, how issues of theory development and testing should be addressed in JAIS submissions, and general notes on the disciplinary policies and norms in the information systems field. At least two JAIS editorial board members review each published editorial note.
JAIS does not have formal restrictions on length.However, all manuscripts should be written concisely to avoid unnecessary length. Manuscripts that are more than 15,000 words are very likely to receive extra scrutiny from the editors. An approximate guide for Research Perspectives and Editorial Notes is 10,000 words.
Prospective authors for JAIS publication should submit their manuscript double-spaced using Arial 11pt. All references should follow the American Psychological Association (6th ed.) style. Reviews are double-blind, so the authors' names should not appear in any obvious way within the document. The JAIS Submission Style Guide is an excellent source for authors; Section 6 within the guide contains examples of APA-style in-text citations and references.
Articles are to be submitted to the JAIS online review system: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/jais.
The official language of the Journal of AIS is English. Therefore all submissions need to be checked and edited for correct English before submission. Submission to JAIS implies the authors' certification that the manuscript is not copyrighted and is not currently under review in any other journal or conference.
The body of the article is restricted to text, tables, and figures and should represent a stand-alone document. This will ensure the widest accessibility even in less technologically endowed environments. Authors can, if necessary, submit text, tables, figures, and appendices in separate files. Links and multimedia supplements should be included in one or more appendices.
To ensure validity of empirical studies and meta-analyses JAIS asks manuscripts which use SEM techniques to provide a full correlation matrix or covariation matrix as a part of the article’s appendix. Editors and reviewers can ask authors to provide a complete dataset during the review for testing and validation of executed statistical analyses. In such cases, authors are expected to provide the dataset as a condition for publishing the article. See JAIS Data Policies.
To avoid any misunderstanding regarding originality of submission, the authors are expected to provide full information about authorship, pre-submission history, earlier related publications and necessary acknowledgements.
Submitting a Cover Letter
Authors should submit a cover letter with their submission. The cover letter should contain the following information:
- The manuscript category of submission.
- The manuscript's word count, including references and appendices.
- The names of 2-3 potential Senior Editor(s) from the JAIS Senior Editor board appropriate to handle the manuscript.
- The names of any Senior Editor with whom any of the authors has a conflict of interest. Conflict of interests include: individuals for whom the author has served as an SE on a paper, individuals with whom an author has co-authored in the past 5 years; active co-authors; colleagues from the same university; friends; co-organizers of conference activities in the past 5 years, current, or in the upcoming 3 years; supervisors; supervisees; joint fundee; program manager of funds; co-author on funding application; relative.
- A declaration of any closely related research that has been published or submitted for publication elsewhere. Closely related research includes: research by any of the authors that investigates one, or more, of the same central constructs and that has been published in, submitted to, or planned for submission to, another journal or conference; research by any of the authors using the same data set that has been published in, submitted to, or planned for submission to, another journal or conference.
- A notification if the paper is a revision of previously submitted paper to JAIS. Only papers that received an invitation for revision (minor revision, major revision, reject/resubmit) may be resubmitted to JAIS. Papers rejected from the journal or from a special issue of the journal are not invited for revision unless specifically mentioned in the Senior Editor’s report.
If disclosures need to be made against point 5 above, then the authors should provide an explanation as to how the current paper offers a contribution over and above that which has appeared before or been submitted for publication elsewhere. For papers that have appeared in a conference proceedings, the authors should explain how they have improved and extended the paper over and above the conference publication.
If the authors wish, the cover letter may contain a description of the paper’s review path to this point, including other journals the paper has been reviewed at and how many rounds the paper was revised before withdrawal or rejection.
Important: Please note -- the cover letter should NOT contain suggestions for reviewers.Cover letters containing suggestions for reviewers will be returned to authors for removal of the suggestions.
Note that it is strongly recommended that authors obtain feedback on working versions of a paper before submission. Workshops and conference presentations are an excellent means of obtaining feedback, and information about prior presentations is generally viewed positively.
Reviews in JAIS are double blind. Authors do not know who reviews their paper, and reviewers do not know the names of the authors. The Senior Editor and the Editor-in-Chief know the names of all involved. Therefore, the authors should write their submission and use references in such a manner as to not reveal their identity.
Finally, please note that at least one of the authors of any manuscript submitted must be an AIS member.