Paper Number
ICIS2025-2171
Paper Type
Complete
Abstract
Building on our previous framework for Free Will (2021) we develop an innovative new framework built upon the old information-decision-action (IDA) cycle, which we extend into a more contemporary informating-decision-action-willing cycle (IDAW). Through this framework, we ask: are AI and big tech undermining liberal democracies through technologies that disturb people’s ability to express free will? We lay out the philosophical position on free will known as metaphysical libertarian incompatibilism, following Kane’s and showing how it can be combined with Taylor’s notion of agency. We then examine its differences to political libertarianism, and its alignment with liberal democracies. We briefly present four cases of concern focusing on each of the four dimensions of the framework, where the advent of artificial intelligence in its current form –the surveillance-intention economy brought to us by billionaire political libertarians – presents, we argue, a potential threat to our ability to experience and express free will.
Recommended Citation
Kreps, David and Rowe, Frantz, "Free Will in action in a digital and AI world" (2025). ICIS 2025 Proceedings. 17.
https://aisel.aisnet.org/icis2025/is_researchmethods/is_researchmethods/17
Free Will in action in a digital and AI world
Building on our previous framework for Free Will (2021) we develop an innovative new framework built upon the old information-decision-action (IDA) cycle, which we extend into a more contemporary informating-decision-action-willing cycle (IDAW). Through this framework, we ask: are AI and big tech undermining liberal democracies through technologies that disturb people’s ability to express free will? We lay out the philosophical position on free will known as metaphysical libertarian incompatibilism, following Kane’s and showing how it can be combined with Taylor’s notion of agency. We then examine its differences to political libertarianism, and its alignment with liberal democracies. We briefly present four cases of concern focusing on each of the four dimensions of the framework, where the advent of artificial intelligence in its current form –the surveillance-intention economy brought to us by billionaire political libertarians – presents, we argue, a potential threat to our ability to experience and express free will.
When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.
Comments
25-Research