Unpacking complexities of mega-scale public sector information technology projects: An ecosystem perspective

Authors

Isabelle Fagnot, Audencia Business School, FranceFollow
Chen Ye, Purdue University Northwest, Indiana, USA.Follow
Kevin Desouza, Arizona State University, PhoenixFollow

Abstract

Mega-scale information technology (IT) projects in the public sector are significant undertakings operating within an ecosystem of stakeholders, resources, and constraints. The track record of these projects is abysmal. Employing an ecosystems lens, we study three failed mega-scale public sector IT projects: the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation’s (FBI) Virtual Case File (VCF), the U.S.federal government’s HealthCare.gov project, and Great Britain’s National Programme for IT (NPfIT). A forensic analysis of these projects was conducted employing the Qualitative Media Analysis (QMA) methodology. The findings suggest several stakeholders in a public IT project assume roles analogous to different types of species in an ecosystem, with the public agency sponsoring the project as the keystone species. Specifically, the findings show that the public agency is susceptible to failure in hiring key personnel with proper knowledge and experience, and failure in responding to early signals alerting the impending implosion of the project ecosystem. In addition, flawed relationships between the public agency and contractors, and flawed relationship between the legislature and the public agency also contributed significantly to project failure.

Recommended Citation

Fagnot, Isabelle; Ye, Chen; and Desouza, Kevin (2018) "Unpacking complexities of mega-scale public sector information technology projects: An ecosystem perspective," Systèmes d'Information et Management: Vol. 23: Iss. 2, Article 2.
Available at: https://aisel.aisnet.org/sim/vol23/iss2/2