Paper Number
ICIS2026-2408
Paper Type
Short
Abstract
Artificial intelligence (AI) increasingly evaluates and selects content, shaping what users ultimately encounter. We examine whether content selected through AI evaluators differs from human-selected content in downstream emotional responses and willingness to pay (WTP). Professional experts created five text-based advertising storyboards, of which 176 human evaluators and nine LLM-based AI evaluators independently rated for emotional impact. The highest-rated storyboard from each source was used in a 2 × 2 experiment crossing selection source (AI-selected vs. human-selected) and media format (text vs. visual) with 713 participants. Participants exposed to AI-selected content reported stronger emotional responses and higher WTP, and mediation analysis identified a significant indirect pathway through emotion. Media richness did not consistently enhance WTP. These findings conceptualize AI evaluation as a selection process and identify emotion as one downstream pathway linking AI-based selection to economic valuation.
Recommended Citation
Kim, Jin Sik; Koo, Thomas K. B.; Kim, Seong Dae; and Im, Subin, "When AI Evaluates: Emotional Pathways to Willingness to Pay" (2026). ICIS 2026 Proceedings. 19.
https://aisel.aisnet.org/icis2026/user_engage/user_engage/19
When AI Evaluates: Emotional Pathways to Willingness to Pay
Artificial intelligence (AI) increasingly evaluates and selects content, shaping what users ultimately encounter. We examine whether content selected through AI evaluators differs from human-selected content in downstream emotional responses and willingness to pay (WTP). Professional experts created five text-based advertising storyboards, of which 176 human evaluators and nine LLM-based AI evaluators independently rated for emotional impact. The highest-rated storyboard from each source was used in a 2 × 2 experiment crossing selection source (AI-selected vs. human-selected) and media format (text vs. visual) with 713 participants. Participants exposed to AI-selected content reported stronger emotional responses and higher WTP, and mediation analysis identified a significant indirect pathway through emotion. Media richness did not consistently enhance WTP. These findings conceptualize AI evaluation as a selection process and identify emotion as one downstream pathway linking AI-based selection to economic valuation.
When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.
Comments
14_User_behavior