Paper Number
ICIS2026-3466
Paper Type
Short
Abstract
Digital labor platforms make worker faces visible, allowing a profile photograph to convey categorical information about perceived racial presentation and evaluator-specific relational information through buyer-seller facial similarity. We examine how these cues jointly shape hiring on Fiverr. Study 1 analyzes observed-hiring and comparison dyads using two-way clustered linear probability models, residualized similarity, and seller-stratified conditional logit. Facial similarity is positively associated with hiring, but it does not uniformly narrow racial disparities. Black-presenting sellers face the clearest baseline disadvantage and show no compensatory similarity effect, whereas race-specific associations emerge for Middle Eastern- and White-presenting sellers. Building on the continuum model of impression formation, we theorize that evaluator-specific relational information receives less evaluative weight when judgments remain strongly anchored in categorical information. Study 2 uses GenAI as a planned causal probe of this weighting mechanism under race-preserving facial manipulation. The findings identify a boundary on relational updating under persistent categorical visibility.
Recommended Citation
Jiang, Yuting; Li, Yijing; and Liu, Fei, "Designing for Relational Similarity: Facial Similarity and Racial Disadvantage in Digital Labor Platforms" (2026). ICIS 2026 Proceedings. 17.
https://aisel.aisnet.org/icis2026/society/society/17
Designing for Relational Similarity: Facial Similarity and Racial Disadvantage in Digital Labor Platforms
Digital labor platforms make worker faces visible, allowing a profile photograph to convey categorical information about perceived racial presentation and evaluator-specific relational information through buyer-seller facial similarity. We examine how these cues jointly shape hiring on Fiverr. Study 1 analyzes observed-hiring and comparison dyads using two-way clustered linear probability models, residualized similarity, and seller-stratified conditional logit. Facial similarity is positively associated with hiring, but it does not uniformly narrow racial disparities. Black-presenting sellers face the clearest baseline disadvantage and show no compensatory similarity effect, whereas race-specific associations emerge for Middle Eastern- and White-presenting sellers. Building on the continuum model of impression formation, we theorize that evaluator-specific relational information receives less evaluative weight when judgments remain strongly anchored in categorical information. Study 2 uses GenAI as a planned causal probe of this weighting mechanism under race-preserving facial manipulation. The findings identify a boundary on relational updating under persistent categorical visibility.
When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.
Comments
06_Societal_impacts