Paper Number
ICIS2026-3057
Paper Type
Completed
Abstract
When consumers learn of a data breach, do they react based on personal risk or moral judgment? We draw on cognitive appraisal theory and construal level theory, which generate opposing predictions, to investigate whether potential victims or unaffected non-customers react more strongly to a data breach. Across three experiments on Prolific (one scenario-based experiment with 568 U.S. participants and two real-life replications following breaches at Telus in Canada and Odido in the Netherlands), we consistently find that unaffected non-customers react more negatively than the firm’s own customers, who are potential victims. This pattern holds across attitude, trust, satisfaction, and word-of-mouth, supporting a construal level explanation in which data breaches are primarily construed as corporate scandals rather than personal privacy threats. Reputational consequences extend beyond the affected customer base. We discuss implications for the archetypical problem behind a data breach, research on privacy violations, and possible avenues for future research.
Recommended Citation
Schlackl, Frederic and Pethig, Florian, "Disentangling Reactions to Data Breaches: Evidence from Mobile Service Providers" (2026). ICIS 2026 Proceedings. 12.
https://aisel.aisnet.org/icis2026/security/security/12
Disentangling Reactions to Data Breaches: Evidence from Mobile Service Providers
When consumers learn of a data breach, do they react based on personal risk or moral judgment? We draw on cognitive appraisal theory and construal level theory, which generate opposing predictions, to investigate whether potential victims or unaffected non-customers react more strongly to a data breach. Across three experiments on Prolific (one scenario-based experiment with 568 U.S. participants and two real-life replications following breaches at Telus in Canada and Odido in the Netherlands), we consistently find that unaffected non-customers react more negatively than the firm’s own customers, who are potential victims. This pattern holds across attitude, trust, satisfaction, and word-of-mouth, supporting a construal level explanation in which data breaches are primarily construed as corporate scandals rather than personal privacy threats. Reputational consequences extend beyond the affected customer base. We discuss implications for the archetypical problem behind a data breach, research on privacy violations, and possible avenues for future research.
When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.
Comments
08_Cybersecurity_and_privacy