AIS Insights AI Podcast
Paper Number
ICIS2026-3242
Paper Type
Completed
Abstract
Digital platforms increasingly use endorsement badges and punitive badges to steer consumer demand, yet their structural impact on choice remains under-explored. This research conceptualizes badges as choice architecture tools designed to induce "decoy-like effects" without altering choice set composition, simply by altering perceived dominance relationships. Through two randomized online experiments (N=1,400), we compare traditional decoy effects induced through choice set expansion against decoy-like effects induced through badges. Our results demonstrate that endorsement badges mimic traditional decoys, increasing the respective target choice share. Furthermore, punitive badges effectively steer demand toward intended targets by retroactively transforming existing options into asymmetrically dominated decoys. These findings contribute to digital platforms literature by framing the use of badges as a strategic manipulation of dominance relationships and highlight the potency of badges for platform governance.
Recommended Citation
Ben Messaoud, Sarah and Kraemer, Jan, "Badges of Influence: How Digital Platforms Induce Decoy-Like Effects to Steer Consumer Choice" (2026). ICIS 2026 Proceedings. 17.
https://aisel.aisnet.org/icis2026/platforms/platforms/17
Badges of Influence: How Digital Platforms Induce Decoy-Like Effects to Steer Consumer Choice
Digital platforms increasingly use endorsement badges and punitive badges to steer consumer demand, yet their structural impact on choice remains under-explored. This research conceptualizes badges as choice architecture tools designed to induce "decoy-like effects" without altering choice set composition, simply by altering perceived dominance relationships. Through two randomized online experiments (N=1,400), we compare traditional decoy effects induced through choice set expansion against decoy-like effects induced through badges. Our results demonstrate that endorsement badges mimic traditional decoys, increasing the respective target choice share. Furthermore, punitive badges effectively steer demand toward intended targets by retroactively transforming existing options into asymmetrically dominated decoys. These findings contribute to digital platforms literature by framing the use of badges as a strategic manipulation of dominance relationships and highlight the potency of badges for platform governance.
When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.
Comments
17_Platforms_sharing_crowds