Paper Number
ICIS2026-2460
Paper Type
Short
Abstract
Although e-commerce platforms increasingly deploy crowd judging to resolve transaction disputes, the way dispute materials are presented remains a critical factor shaping jurors' fairness perceptions. This study examines whether platform-led emotion neutralization influences jurors' perceived fairness by altering their cognitive processing, and investigates how emotional expression structure and product type jointly moderate this relationship. Through a randomized experiment, we compare emotion preservation with emotion neutralization across three emotional expression structures—buyer-unilateral, seller-unilateral, and bilateral expressions—and two product types, namely utilitarian and hedonic disputes. We theorize that emotion neutralization operates as a dual-impact intervention, which enhances perceived objectivity but simultaneously undermines perceived representational fidelity. These competing mechanisms jointly shape jurors’ evaluations of platform governance fairness, with their relative dominance contingent on both the specific emotional expression structure and whether the disputed product is utilitarian or hedonic.
Recommended Citation
Li, Zengxi; Yue, Wei Thoo; and Lee, Zach W. Y., "Should E-commerce Platforms Neutralize Emotion in Dispute? A Dual-Pathway Model of Perceived Fairness in Crowd Judging" (2026). ICIS 2026 Proceedings. 13.
https://aisel.aisnet.org/icis2026/platforms/platforms/13
Should E-commerce Platforms Neutralize Emotion in Dispute? A Dual-Pathway Model of Perceived Fairness in Crowd Judging
Although e-commerce platforms increasingly deploy crowd judging to resolve transaction disputes, the way dispute materials are presented remains a critical factor shaping jurors' fairness perceptions. This study examines whether platform-led emotion neutralization influences jurors' perceived fairness by altering their cognitive processing, and investigates how emotional expression structure and product type jointly moderate this relationship. Through a randomized experiment, we compare emotion preservation with emotion neutralization across three emotional expression structures—buyer-unilateral, seller-unilateral, and bilateral expressions—and two product types, namely utilitarian and hedonic disputes. We theorize that emotion neutralization operates as a dual-impact intervention, which enhances perceived objectivity but simultaneously undermines perceived representational fidelity. These competing mechanisms jointly shape jurors’ evaluations of platform governance fairness, with their relative dominance contingent on both the specific emotional expression structure and whether the disputed product is utilitarian or hedonic.
When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.
Comments
17_Platforms_sharing_crowds