AIS Insights AI Podcast
Paper Number
ICIS2026-3298
Paper Type
Completed
Abstract
IT renewal, replacing an organization’s core digital system while the legacy system remains operational, presents organizations with challenges distinctive from greenfield system development. This study draws on Clegg’s Circuits of Power framework to understand these challenges. Through a longitudinal case study at a government organization, we examine how power flows through episodic decisions, shared meanings, and infrastructural arrangements. We find that renewal directions change when these circuits converge around obligatory passage points; nodes through which subsequent actions must pass. External interventions such as regulatory deadlines and bureaucratic external assessments reshape the rules of meaning under which internal claims are heard, enabling such convergences to form. The paper extends IT renewal theory by showing how power operates through circuit convergence as a mechanism shaping which renewal paths persist.
Recommended Citation
Grasmeijer, René; Elshan, Edona; and van den Hooff, Bart, "Power in IT Renewal: How Power Dynamics Shape the Trajectory of Large-Scale System Replacements" (2026). ICIS 2026 Proceedings. 14.
https://aisel.aisnet.org/icis2026/implement/implement/14
Power in IT Renewal: How Power Dynamics Shape the Trajectory of Large-Scale System Replacements
IT renewal, replacing an organization’s core digital system while the legacy system remains operational, presents organizations with challenges distinctive from greenfield system development. This study draws on Clegg’s Circuits of Power framework to understand these challenges. Through a longitudinal case study at a government organization, we examine how power flows through episodic decisions, shared meanings, and infrastructural arrangements. We find that renewal directions change when these circuits converge around obligatory passage points; nodes through which subsequent actions must pass. External interventions such as regulatory deadlines and bureaucratic external assessments reshape the rules of meaning under which internal claims are heard, enabling such convergences to form. The paper extends IT renewal theory by showing how power operates through circuit convergence as a mechanism shaping which renewal paths persist.
When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.
Comments
12_Implementation_and_organizing