Paper Number
ICIS2026-3067
Paper Type
Completed
Abstract
Policymakers such as the U.S. Federal Trade Commission mandate explicit disclosure of incentivized reviews. This paper examines the consequences of such mandatory disclosure. Given that the ultimate purpose of incentivized reviews is to assist consumer decision making, this study focuses on how disclosure affects perceived review usefulness. The results show that explicit disclosure indirectly enhances perceived usefulness by improving review quality. However, disclosure labels also directly reduce perceived usefulness by triggering fairness concerns and discouraging consumers from reading these reviews. Importantly, the negative direct effect outweighs the positive indirect effect, resulting in an overall decline in perceived usefulness. To mitigate this adverse effect, this paper further proposes and empirically tests the role of platform-based quality certification in alleviating the negative impact of disclosure on perceived usefulness.
Recommended Citation
Sun, Peiliang; Zheng, Mingxin; and Liu, Jingwen, "Does Transparency Always Benefit? The Effect of Explicit Disclosure of Incentivized Reviews on Review Usefulness" (2026). ICIS 2026 Proceedings. 9.
https://aisel.aisnet.org/icis2026/ethics/ethics/9
Does Transparency Always Benefit? The Effect of Explicit Disclosure of Incentivized Reviews on Review Usefulness
Policymakers such as the U.S. Federal Trade Commission mandate explicit disclosure of incentivized reviews. This paper examines the consequences of such mandatory disclosure. Given that the ultimate purpose of incentivized reviews is to assist consumer decision making, this study focuses on how disclosure affects perceived review usefulness. The results show that explicit disclosure indirectly enhances perceived usefulness by improving review quality. However, disclosure labels also directly reduce perceived usefulness by triggering fairness concerns and discouraging consumers from reading these reviews. Importantly, the negative direct effect outweighs the positive indirect effect, resulting in an overall decline in perceived usefulness. To mitigate this adverse effect, this paper further proposes and empirically tests the role of platform-based quality certification in alleviating the negative impact of disclosure on perceived usefulness.
When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.
Comments
05_Responsibility_and_ethics