Paper Number

ICIS2026-2131

Paper Type

Completed

Abstract

Generative artificial intelligence is transforming research integrity in scholarly publishing by making misconduct easier to produce, harder to detect, and increasingly difficult to govern. We conducted a scoping thematic review of 68 peer-reviewed studies published from 2016 to 2026, analysed through inductive thematic analysis. Our review shows that, while prior studies document specific phenomena such as AI-generated text, hallucinated citations, paper mills, statistical anomalies, and post-publication scrutiny, the literature remains fragmented and largely descriptive. We identify five themes and fifteen sub-themes capturing the social, technical, and institutional dimensions of AI-mediated research integrity. The paper makes three contributions: it conceptualises AI-mediated research integrity as a sociotechnical governance problem; develops a constitutive mechanism-based model showing how interacting components produce and reproduce system-level integrity vulnerability; and identifies three persistent tensions: escalation between AI-enabled misconduct and AI-enabled detection, threshold ambiguity around acceptable AI use, and governance lag between technological change and institutional response.

Comments

05_Responsibility_and_ethics

Share

COinS
 
Dec 14th, 12:00 AM

When AI Enables Misconduct and Detection: Research Integrity in Scholarly Publishing

Generative artificial intelligence is transforming research integrity in scholarly publishing by making misconduct easier to produce, harder to detect, and increasingly difficult to govern. We conducted a scoping thematic review of 68 peer-reviewed studies published from 2016 to 2026, analysed through inductive thematic analysis. Our review shows that, while prior studies document specific phenomena such as AI-generated text, hallucinated citations, paper mills, statistical anomalies, and post-publication scrutiny, the literature remains fragmented and largely descriptive. We identify five themes and fifteen sub-themes capturing the social, technical, and institutional dimensions of AI-mediated research integrity. The paper makes three contributions: it conceptualises AI-mediated research integrity as a sociotechnical governance problem; develops a constitutive mechanism-based model showing how interacting components produce and reproduce system-level integrity vulnerability; and identifies three persistent tensions: escalation between AI-enabled misconduct and AI-enabled detection, threshold ambiguity around acceptable AI use, and governance lag between technological change and institutional response.

When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.