AIS Insights AI Podcast
Paper Number
ICIS2026-2027
Paper Type
Short
Abstract
Adolescents (aged 13–17) are vulnerable to risks on social media. The problem begins at sign-up, where users agree to terms of conditions that are legally valid but ethically weak. We aim to develop a theory of the problem and a theory of the solution using a sequential mixed-methods design. We conduct semi-structured interviews with adolescent–parent dyads to examine how consent is interpreted. Our preliminary findings identify consent opacity as a mechanism through which ethical consent fails, driven by adolescents’ bounded rationality and resulting in mechanical acceptance of complex terms. We then identify authentic consent design as a solution through cognitive load reduction and assessment mechanisms that support comprehension before agreement. In the next phase, we will continue data collection and design an experiment to test our ethical consent design. This study contributes to IS research by explaining why consent fails and offering a design-based path toward ethical consent.
Recommended Citation
Tanyel, Ilkay Nehir and Lin, Fangyu, "When Clicking Accept Is Not Enough: Adolescents' Experience of Consent Opacity on Social Media" (2026). ICIS 2026 Proceedings. 3.
https://aisel.aisnet.org/icis2026/ethics/ethics/3
When Clicking Accept Is Not Enough: Adolescents' Experience of Consent Opacity on Social Media
Adolescents (aged 13–17) are vulnerable to risks on social media. The problem begins at sign-up, where users agree to terms of conditions that are legally valid but ethically weak. We aim to develop a theory of the problem and a theory of the solution using a sequential mixed-methods design. We conduct semi-structured interviews with adolescent–parent dyads to examine how consent is interpreted. Our preliminary findings identify consent opacity as a mechanism through which ethical consent fails, driven by adolescents’ bounded rationality and resulting in mechanical acceptance of complex terms. We then identify authentic consent design as a solution through cognitive load reduction and assessment mechanisms that support comprehension before agreement. In the next phase, we will continue data collection and design an experiment to test our ethical consent design. This study contributes to IS research by explaining why consent fails and offering a design-based path toward ethical consent.
When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.
Comments
05_Responsibility_and_ethics