Paper Number
ICIS2026-3390
Paper Type
Completed
Abstract
Data governance research recognizes that formal governance acquires meaning through situated interpretation and enactment. Yet, little is known about the normative assumptions underlying actors' judgments when data governance is responsible. We address this gap by conceptualizing them as normative reference points (NRPs) that guide how responsibility is understood, assigned, and justified in governance practice. Drawing on an abductive analysis of qualitative interviews, we identify five NRPs and show how their relations constitute two modes of responsibility enactment: stabilizing and deliberating. The stabilizing mode renders responsibility actionable through concentration, routinization, and traceability, whereas the deliberating mode keeps responsibility open to reflection, stakeholder consideration, and case-sensitive judgment. We contribute threefold. First, we develop NRPs as a vocabulary for theorizing the plurality of responsibility in data governance. Second, we theorize the tension generated by the relation between the stabilizing and deliberating modes. Third, we show how data governance practices mediate this tension.
Recommended Citation
Richter, Kenneth; Zimmer, Markus P.; Werner, Matthias; and Drews, Paul, "Responsibility in Data Governance has Many Faces: Theorizing Normative Reference Points" (2026). ICIS 2026 Proceedings. 18.
https://aisel.aisnet.org/icis2026/datamgmt/datamgmt/18
Responsibility in Data Governance has Many Faces: Theorizing Normative Reference Points
Data governance research recognizes that formal governance acquires meaning through situated interpretation and enactment. Yet, little is known about the normative assumptions underlying actors' judgments when data governance is responsible. We address this gap by conceptualizing them as normative reference points (NRPs) that guide how responsibility is understood, assigned, and justified in governance practice. Drawing on an abductive analysis of qualitative interviews, we identify five NRPs and show how their relations constitute two modes of responsibility enactment: stabilizing and deliberating. The stabilizing mode renders responsibility actionable through concentration, routinization, and traceability, whereas the deliberating mode keeps responsibility open to reflection, stakeholder consideration, and case-sensitive judgment. We contribute threefold. First, we develop NRPs as a vocabulary for theorizing the plurality of responsibility in data governance. Second, we theorize the tension generated by the relation between the stabilizing and deliberating modes. Third, we show how data governance practices mediate this tension.
When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.
Comments
07_Data_management