Paper Number

ICIS2025-2178

Paper Type

Short

Abstract

This paper investigates the role of social comparison in online chat groups for check-ins (OCGCs), specialized digital environments where users engage in self-regulation practices by posting goal-related check-in messages. Drawing on social comparison theory in interpersonal communication, we identify two IT-enabled communication patterns in OCGCs—the Reporting Pattern (RP) and the Non-Reporting Pattern (NRP)—and classify users’ social comparison perceptions into horizontal and vertical dimensions based on these patterns. Using a secondary dataset from a large-scale real-world OCGC context, our analysis reveals that horizontal comparison triggered by RP enhances user engagement by fostering a sense of solidarity, whereas vertical comparison triggered by NRP reduces engagement by evoking status-based evaluations. These findings offer new insights into the nuanced impact of technology-mediated social comparison in self-regulation communities and provide practical implications for OCGCs operators as well as businesses aiming to design more engaging online communities.

Comments

16-UserBehavior

Download

Share

COinS
 
Dec 14th, 12:00 AM

Unveiling the Influence of Social Comparison in User Engagement in Online Chat Groups for Check-ins

This paper investigates the role of social comparison in online chat groups for check-ins (OCGCs), specialized digital environments where users engage in self-regulation practices by posting goal-related check-in messages. Drawing on social comparison theory in interpersonal communication, we identify two IT-enabled communication patterns in OCGCs—the Reporting Pattern (RP) and the Non-Reporting Pattern (NRP)—and classify users’ social comparison perceptions into horizontal and vertical dimensions based on these patterns. Using a secondary dataset from a large-scale real-world OCGC context, our analysis reveals that horizontal comparison triggered by RP enhances user engagement by fostering a sense of solidarity, whereas vertical comparison triggered by NRP reduces engagement by evoking status-based evaluations. These findings offer new insights into the nuanced impact of technology-mediated social comparison in self-regulation communities and provide practical implications for OCGCs operators as well as businesses aiming to design more engaging online communities.

When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.