Paper Type
Complete
Abstract
The Video Assistant Referee (VAR) as an information system (IS) supporting soccer referees is a success, at least according to the IS Success Model. However, football associations like Sweden discontinue its use mainly based on fan protests, such that it is also a failure, according to IS discontinuation literature. In this paper we analyze this paradox with a focus on the VAR in European soccer leagues. We provide a systems perspective emphasizing IS success and failure emerge from the dual role of IS: as internal components that enhance the functioning of a specific work system and as interconnected elements that interact with broader socio-technical systems, in our case professional soccer and a professional soccer match. This systems perspective complements the well-established variance and process perspectives enabling an analysis of success and failure in parallel.
Paper Number
1181
Recommended Citation
Laumer, Sven and Maier, Christian, "The Video Assistant Referee: A Systems Perspective on IS Success and Failure" (2025). AMCIS 2025 Proceedings. 33.
https://aisel.aisnet.org/amcis2025/sigadit/sigadit/33
The Video Assistant Referee: A Systems Perspective on IS Success and Failure
The Video Assistant Referee (VAR) as an information system (IS) supporting soccer referees is a success, at least according to the IS Success Model. However, football associations like Sweden discontinue its use mainly based on fan protests, such that it is also a failure, according to IS discontinuation literature. In this paper we analyze this paradox with a focus on the VAR in European soccer leagues. We provide a systems perspective emphasizing IS success and failure emerge from the dual role of IS: as internal components that enhance the functioning of a specific work system and as interconnected elements that interact with broader socio-technical systems, in our case professional soccer and a professional soccer match. This systems perspective complements the well-established variance and process perspectives enabling an analysis of success and failure in parallel.
When commenting on articles, please be friendly, welcoming, respectful and abide by the AIS eLibrary Discussion Thread Code of Conduct posted here.
Comments
SIGADIT